Considering a smart speaker with a screen? It’s the newest tech toy on the market, bringing more visual entertainment and information to the growing trend of having a digital butler. You might be deciding between Google Nest Hub and Amazon Echo Show, but which one should you choose and why? I’ll put them head to head here to see which platform comes out on top.
Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5: Design, Size & Styling
There’s a clear winner here and it doesn’t take much to see. While the Amazon Echo Show is wide and fat and bulky, the Google Nest Hub is sleek, compact and… pretty.
I score this one for Google Nest Hub
What can Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5 do?
By and large these devices perform all the same basic functions:
- playing music (Google Play Music, Amazon Music, Spotify)
- answering questions
- You can make video calls
- setting timers
- controlling nearly any Smart Home gadgets like lights, thermostats, door locks and more
- telling you about your day; see more below
- getting news, weather and traffic info
- making conversions: money, measurements, time
- make phone calls
- look up phone numbers (and call them)
- add items to to-do lists and create reminders
- make calendar appointments; depending on your OS, see below
Google Nest Hub has a long list of apps and other devices it’s compatible with, while Amazon’s Show does too… it just depends on the specific thing you might want to control or connect.
Both the Google Nest Hub and Amazon Echo Show stack up here evenly. It’s a tie.
Where your choice might be made for you is in the things they don’t both do…
Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5: What don’t they both do?
You can use the Google Nest Hub to control your Chromecast TV, but not the Show.
Echo Show will let you order stuff off amazon just by asking, while Google has no built in shopping platform.
Best Assistant at answering questions & executing commands
I put the Echo Show and Hub head to head in a series of commands:
- How much is 1 stick of butter in cups?
- How do I say please move your car in Vietnamese?
- Turn all my lights pink
- Give me a news update
- Find a Thai restaurant near me
- Tell me a joke
Best Assistant Personality & Customization
Google Assistant has a nice, natural sounding voice with a human tone and cadence. Her interactions can often be punctuated with little extras, like a rim shot after a silly joke.
Amazon’s Alexa still sounds stiff and robotic and stilted.
Here, my pick is for Google Assistant, hands down.
Screen & Video quality: Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5
The screen on Google Nest Hub is 7″ LCD touchscreen display, and a resolution of 1280X800. You’d think that’s basically 720p HD, but the screen is sharp, detailed and bright. The Hub also adds something called Ambient EQ light sensor. The sensor detects the amount of light in the room and adjusts the screen brightness and colours so it looks natural and right.
The Amazon Echo Show 5 has a 5.5” video screen. It too is clear and bright and easy on the eyes. There’s also adaptive brightness built in here too.
This one is a tie.
What videos can I watch on Google Nest Hub & Amazon Echo Show 5
On Amazon Echo Show you can watch anything on Amazon Prime TV. Wheee! You can also watch YouTube.
On Google Nest Hub, you can watch YouTube. Boooo.
Winner: Amazon Echo Show 5
Sound Quality: Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5
Google and Amazon have both been making pretty big strides in making these devices sound good. Amazon’s even brought out a Subwoofer for its Echo devices.
When it comes to overall sound quality between these devices, though, that bulkier design helps Amazon.
The Echo Show’s speaker sounds good and strong. The bass is pretty rich on this speaker, and it’s more than loud enough for my space even at just half the volume level. The sound overall is full and rich and I’m more than happy with what I’m getting from it.
The Google Nest Hub, still sounds good, though it leans a bit toward the high end when it comes to sound quality. I listened to jazz and it sounded nice, but when I put on more bass-heavy music, say something like Dre’s Next Episode, it was still pretty thin on the bass.
Neither of these speakers is what audiophiles would call high fidelity. It’s a tie on audio quality here.
Music Services: Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5
Amazon Echo can access Amazon Music, Spotify and TuneIn Radio.
Google Hub can utilize Google Play Music, Spotify, and Apple Music (when used with Apple devices only). So if you’re really attached to your Apple Music library, there’s only one choice for you here: get Google.
With that said, both Google Play and Amazon Music let you access a free version of the service that’s pretty great, actually. I’ve been running the free version of both on each of the Echo and Hub and I’m more than happy with what I get, though the content is somewhat limited. Of course if you have Spotify, you can use that on either device, though you must have the premium account on Spotify to have it play properly over your smart speakers.
The winner when it comes to music is a tie if you’re Android and Google Home if you’re Apple.
Phone integration: Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5
Both Amazon Echo and and Google Home are compatible with many different smartphone platforms, including Android, Apple and more.
Google Home is definitely made to work closely with its own Pixel line of smartphones, and other Android phones and you may enjoy a more seamless experience if this is the platform you’ve got.
Surprisingly, you can still do a lot if you have an Apple iPhone. Some of the things you can’t do, however include asking Google Assistant to read your calendar.
As far as Amazon Echo Show goes, the device may seem to be geared towards the Android world, but again, there’s a lot you can do with your Apple iPhone.
With Echo you can add your calendar to Alexa’s brain. She’ll integrate with Apple Calendar/iCloud, Microsoft Outlook and Office, plus the G-suite of apps and functions from Google. Want to hear about your day or list of appointments from your Apple calendar? Alexa will tell you.
The winner when it comes to compatibility and integration: Amazon Echo if you have Apple, and it’s a tie if you’re Android.
Price: Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5
If price is your deciding factor, here’s the cost:
Amazon Echo Show 5 is $99CAD
Google Nest Hub is $169CAD
Overall winner: Google Nest Hub vs Amazon Echo Show 5
Choosing a winner here is tough, because these devices are quite similar when it comes to specs. Where you’ll break your tie seems to be in which platform you prefer; so if you have a Google Pixelbook and Pixel phone, it makes sense to keep your ecosystem compatible.
If you’re an Apple user who doesn’t want to splash out of the big and expensive (and screenless) HomePod, your choice is for Amazon’s devices, which have more compatibility with your ecosystem.
[amazon_link asins=’B07KD6RCKS,B07KD762C1,B07P6NF9LS’ template=’ProductCarousel’ store=’techgadcanada-20′ marketplace=’CA’ link_id=’f2f4298c-9177-42f8-88a2-f240ce3aea20′]